|
| America's Hidden History: Untold Tales of the First Pilgrims, Fighting Women, and Forgotten Founders Who Shaped a Nation | 
 enlarge | Author: Kenneth C. Davis
Publisher: Collins
Category: Book
List Price: $26.95
Buy New: $16.80
You Save: $10.15 (38%)
New (31) Used (10) from $15.50
Avg. Customer Rating:  28 reviews
Sales Rank: 11555
Media: Hardcover
Number Of Items: 1
Pages: 288
Shipping Weight (lbs): 1
Dimensions (in): 9.1 x 5.7 x 1
ISBN: 0061118184
Dewey Decimal Number: 973.2
EAN: 9780061118180
ASIN: 0061118184
Publication Date: May 1, 2008
Availability: Usually ships in 1-2 business days
Condition: Brand new Book, ALL days Low Price !
|
| Customer Reviews:
| Showing reviews 1-5 of 28 | | NEXT » |
 Honesty and Rigorous Research January 7, 2009
I found this book well researched and very readable and a good primer and springboard for anyone interested in American history.
good book December 19, 2008
I got this book for my birthday and was not sure what to make of it before i read it. After i was do i thought it was well written and i enjoyed it very much
 Cute, Overblown, Light, With Erroneous Sweeping Statements December 6, 2008
5 out of 6 found this review helpful
This is the first book I've read by author Kenneth Davis and it will be my last. He has chosen six stories, but meanders far off the point in telling them and runs fast and loose with his facts and sweeping statements. This is a cute book for 8th graders, but does not add to the literature of colonial days or the beginning of our country.
The first story is really about the Spanish Catholics exterminating the French Protestant presence in South Carolina to the last man, woman and child. OK, that happened and illustrates one of the worst features of Catholic dogma in that heresy must be ruthlessly stamped out, not by converting people, but by killing them, but his account is a popularized one that never scratches the historical surface.
The second tells the story of the Puritan versus Indian confrontation in New England, sympathetically to the Indians. After the first two chapters I concluded that Davis was a anti-religion zealot. He cherry-picks his facts to put the colonists in a bad light, and makes sweeping and sarcastic statements that are only partially correct. The truth is much more complex, but then that wouldn't be as interesting and wouldn't sell books. The author's style is that of a muckraking journalist (are there any other?) rather than that of an historian.
The third essentially says that Washington was a criminal, made unforgivable mistakes as a 21-year old, and caused the Seven Years' War through his fecklessness. Again, the truth is much more complex, although adoring historians have indeed skipped over this part of Washington's life. His responsibility for the Jumonville masacre has been debated for years, but the most telling tidbit that the Davis overlooks was that when Jumonville's brother had Washington in his power, he did not extract vengeance.
The fourth focuses on Dr. Warren, an often overlooked patriot today because he was killed at Bunker Hill in 1775. However, in many respects the author makes out the revolution to be more about money for the merchant class than for the farmers who fought the war. And, of course, the role of the Scotch-Irish in all this is missed, even though most of the principal actors in the 13 colonies on the patriot side were Scotch-Irish. Gee, why? Oops, the author doesn't know.
Aah, then comes a far-foreshortened story of Benedict Arnold. The author attempts to cover in 33 pages what many historians have been unable to capture in extensive tomes. And the author fails miserably except to point out that Arnold accomplished great things for the Patriot cause before he went over to the British. As if no one knew that.
And last comes Shay's Rebellion. Yes, being a soldier in the Continental Army was unrewarding and power and money rapidly went to the lawyers and businessmen in the eastern cities. So, how is that different today? Our country has NEVER rewarded its servicemen adequately for their sacrifices, but it still has done better than any other country. Lawyers, bureaucrats, odious politicians and businessmen always control things in peace time -- soldiers and patriots are only needed in times of national emergency. Then the non-lawyers are called upon to sacrifice for the good of those in power. Still, we're better than all others. This story was perhaps the most egregious chapter in which the author ran fast and loose with pejorative statements, misstatements of fact, and overblown rhetoric. In addition, the author diverts himself to the story of James Wilson, and tends to tar the founding fathers as greedy and unprincipled.
The best treatise in this book was one in the last chapter that almost makes up for the garbage earlier. Unfortunately, this was by Akhil Reed of Yale, but kudos to the author for including it. The earth-shaking fact was that, "... before the American Revolution, no people had ever explicitly voted on their own constitution." Of course, I would direct the reader to look closely at the Pennsylvania Constitution made before the US Constitution for a real appreciation of a people's government. There are also other nuggets such as that most states had taxes that went to supporting each state's approved religion -- something later expressly prohibited in the Constitution. That goes far to understanding the off quoted principle (but inaccurate) of separation of church and state. Also that Washington ad-libbed "so help me God" when he was sworn in as our first president.
All in all, this is a quick one-night read when bored, and hardly worth the price of admission.
America Hidden History December 2, 2008
1 out of 1 found this review helpful
America's Hidden History: Untold Tales of the First Pilgrims, Fighting Women, and Forgotten Founders Who Shaped a Nation
This is a very interesting book and sure opens up a lot of what really went on in our early history. Not all was as well as we were told in school, or what the history books we had told us.
 No Myths Allowed November 26, 2008
1 out of 8 found this review helpful
All nations and religions have basic myths. They don't need to be true. They are meant to teach values and unite people. What myths would this author have at the foundation of the United States? It seems to me that a myth of Thanksgiving, unity, and cooperation with people of different cultures is about as good as a foundation myth gets. But his Op-Ed in the New York Times clearly calls us all fools for celebrating our national myth of Thanksgiving rather than celebrating French pilgrims who were wiped out by Spanish savages, and who left absolutely no cultural legacy.
The United States is no longer allowed to enjoy any positive myths. Profit seekers like Mr. Davis want to destroy any positive mental picture, any ideal for which Americans can strive. Please tell us how Santa Clause is a tool of the evil capitalists and how Rover didn't really go to doggy heaven. That would be really useful journalism.
|
|
|
| |
