Home Wine News Articles Shop for Wine Accessories About Links Downloads Contact

Good Grape Wine Company

Left side of the header
Right side of the header

Breathless News at 11:00

So, Parker breathlessly notes yesterday, as reported by Wine & Spirits Daily:

“One of the biggest stories in my 30 years in the wine field will be the detailed announcement ...officially set for tomorrow…that will shake the fine wine world ......and I am not referring to BOTTLE SHOCK the movie…,”.

So, drum roll please ... the story is that Château Cos-d’Estournel is buying Chateau Montelena in Napa.

Are you kidding me?  One of the biggest stories in the last 30 years?  As a country we’re up to our elbows in debt to the Chinese, beholden to the Middle East and it’s a huge story that a French winery buys a US winery when the US dollar is in the dumper? 

To this we reply:


image

digg this | toast this! | add to del.icio.us | add to newsvine | add to furl | add to reddit |

Posted in, Around the Wine Blogosphere. Permalink | Comments (8) | Print |


Comments

On 07/23, braingirl wrote:

I’m with you. A few people asked me about thsi yesterday, and I just couldn’t imagine what would be so earth shattering. Certainly, there may be business and/or cultural ramifications of which we’re not aware, but so far, ho hum.

On 07/23, Saint Vini wrote:

I don’t understand….he said “in the wine world”, and you then placed it in a geo-political context….....?!?

If you’re in the business or truly want to understand it (which you should if you want to blog about anything beyond who makes the best under $10 Chardonnay and the usual tripe found on wine blogs), then you need to think and dig a little deeper into the significance of this purchase by the French.

Nothwithstanding the irony of the timing (“Bottle Shock” opens next week), this is the first important because its the first serious acquisition in California by a major French producer. Forget Opus One - that was a JV with Mondavi, and forget Dominus - that was a opportunistic purchase of a vineyard from a family needing to sell, then Mouiex built the winery.  And so on….

If you truly know about the French and their historical attitudes toward California wines (have you seen Mondovino?) you would get this and what it truly means (both good and bad).  Again, if you really follow the industry, this has real signifigance beyond whomever got a “98” and who the new winemaker at Chateau de Ego is.  Robert Parker understands that, and so should you.

V

On 07/23, braingirl wrote:

Actually, I think Robert Parker and others still live in a world where the French rule, and many of us understand the wine business quite well, but don’t necessarily agree that one French house *finally* recognizing the importance of Napa as a quality wine center is the most significant. development. ever.

On 07/23, (JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) wrote:

Maybe a Frenchman getting into California wine was big news when George de La Tour started BV a century ago, but since with Domain Chandon, Newton, Domain Carneros, St. Supery, Ch. Potelle, HdV (de Villaine), Roederer - Anderson Valley, Scharrfenberger (Cliquot)-Anderson Valley, Drouhin in Oregon, Dominus, Opus, Mumm, and Tablas Creek we are talking no sea change in attitude, no reason for mindless hysteria about Montelena…just one big, long, appropriate yawn.

On 07/23, (JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) wrote:

In my excitement listing all the French owners and forgetting Remy and Clos du Val, I also forgot to point out that the buyer of Montelena (and owner of Cos) is Swiss, not French. (No, I am not going on to list Hess, Spring Mountain Vyd., Merryvale…because those damned Swiss have such attitudes!)

On 07/23, Jeff wrote:

Thanks for the comments, all.

V - lucid comments, as always.  I’ll disregard the red herring about whether or not I know the business, because, well, I do, insomuch as I know enough that other people read what I have to say, but not to the extent that I understand the 1855 classification and the socio-political context that it drives to today 150 + years later in a global village w/ 2nd growth Chateau’s.

And, I did see Mondovino—twice, even.

But, overall, I don’t care that much. 

Michael Mondavi sums up my reference to geo-political context:

“The Europeans are working with a 60-cent dollar. If I were a European vintner who wanted to expand, now is the best time,” said Michael Mondavi. “It’s the perfect storm, with a strong euro and a weak U.S. economy.”

Other than that, the story is a yawner to me.  Much ado about not much. 

You da man, though, for calling a spade a spade.

Jeff

On 07/24, Steve Heimoff wrote:

Morton hit the nail on the head. The French have been coming here for a long time. Remember what’s his name, whose family sold La Mission Haut-Brion and then he bought a Chardonnay winery on Howell Mountain? I think Parker got a little ahead of himself on this one, mainly due to his Bordeaux-centrism.

On 07/27, Richard Shaffer wrote:

Seems like one of those “announcements” that only people head-down in the insular traditional wine industry space would focus on or even care about.

Big Stories to me in this space are things like: Millenials Love Wine (imports especially); DIRECT Selling; Amazon.freakin.com is about to sell wine DIRECT to you, etc.

People from overseas are buying all kinds of stuff from the US - the dollar sucks right now.

Heck, Anheuser-Busch just sold, too. Much bigger story than Chateau whatcha-ma-call-it.

Richard

Leave a Comment

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

  • @TishWine - welcome back. besides some security fraud, ah, not much happened on Jan 5, 2009 at 8:41pm
  • Blogging and Twittering - say it in 500 words or 140 characters? What if I prefer 500 words? on Jan 5, 2009 at 7:08pm
  • What this recession could mean for nascent wineries - http://tinyurl.com/6wvfsx on Jan 5, 2009 at 4:47pm
  • @drvino - it should be wii fit where you have to approximate harvesting grapes, including navigating terrain on Jan 5, 2009 at 12:26pm
  • I, for one, am glad to be back at work. Glad for the break, but glad to be working, too. on Jan 5, 2009 at 10:29am

Enter your email address for a monthly summary of posts, additional news and information available only to email subscribers. Your email is never rented, nor sold to anybody else!

Search Good Grape